As the years go on, the nature of how connected the Marvel Cinematic
Universe movies are to the Marvel TV shows becomes more and more
tenuous. Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D., the first television show to
ambitiously put itself in Marvel’s shared film universe, was once ripe
with tie ins to the movies and name-drops of the A-list heroes.
Additionally, the plot of Captain America: Winter Soldier was so
intimately connected to the sh
ow that it derailed the conceit of it from a family friendly superhero
adventure series to an intriguing sci-fi spy thriller with surprising
twists and turns. Then, as Marvel’s TV arm exploded with more shows set
in the same universe, the references continued.
In Netflix’s Daredevil, Matt Murdock’s Hell’s Kitchen is in a state of
poverty and high crime only because it is still struggling to recover
after Loki’s invasion from The Avengers. In Agent Carter we meet Edwin
Jarvis, the meek butler who, it turns out, was the inspiration for Tony
Stark’s AI assistant J.A.R.V.I.S. in Iron Man. And when Captain America:
Civil War revealed the existence of an underwater, high security prison
for those with enhanced abilities, Jessica Jones’ supervillain mother
had to come to terms with the fact that she’d be sent there if she were
ever caught. Over the years viewers have come to love these various
connections and subtle moments of world development, and fans
subsequently dissect each new live action Marvel entry to find all the
hidden references. From a business standpoint, this is a great example
of corporate synergy. By alleging that all these titles operate in the
same universe, Marvel is incentivizing viewers to watch every single
title so that they may be rewarded with deeper and deeper story nuance.
However, the problem is that the nature of the combined TV and film
universe is largely an illusion. Ever since S.H.I.E.L.D.’s first season,
the references have become fewer and further between. In fact, the
show’s latest season wished so much to avoid the Marvel film stories
that it went off to the year 2091 to avoid The Avengers completely.
Marvel’s Runaways almost entirely ignores the wider universe it is
supposedly set in (if Wizard is such a big brand why haven’t we seen its
logo anywhere in the movies?). And, in perhaps the most egregious
example, though Netflix’s six shows constantly show us the New York
skyline, the famous Avengers tower is nowhere in sight.
However the most frustrating part of this is that, although the shows
have repeatedly referenced the events of the movies, the movies have
never once referenced anything from the shows. Except, that is, for a
lonely exception. Because, where we would least expect, it turns out
there is exactly one, and only one, instance of something introduced in a
TV show later appearing in the films. What is this all important
reference? Oddly, it's New York's Metro General Hospital.
In Daredevil, we meet and come to love nurse Claire Temple, a gifted
medic who eventually allies with countless heroes and constantly proves
herself more competent than all of them. When we first meet her, she is
working in the crowded and underfunded emergency room of New York’s
Metropolitan General hospital, known to all as Metro General. This is
the first time we are introduced to this unique setting in the Marvel
universe.
Now, fast forward one year and hop into the films, and we visit a very
familiar location. In 2016, Marvel’s ambitious Benedict Cumberbatch-led
film Doctor Strange hit theaters. And, as it turns out, Cumberbatch’s
successful New York neurosurgeon works at none other than our Metro
General Hospital. Lo and behold, the only time a Marvel movie has
referenced a TV show.
Now the two incarnations of the hospital are noticeably different. While
Metro General is referred to as a “rat hole” in Daredevil and is
clearly struggling to fight disrepair (and ninjas), Strange’s Metro
General is one of pristine halls and well to do medical staff. One way
to reconcile this is to assume that Metro General is actually the name
of the hospital franchise, of which there are at least three separate
branches, accounting for the two different versions of the hospital.
However, in all likelihood, this discrepancy is because the cross
reference was most likely not intentional. Metro General is actually the
name of a popular New York hospital in the Marvel comics. So, the two
screenwriters of these projects may have both referenced the comics for
this name without realizing that this ties them together in Marvel's
Cinematic Universe. Nevertheless, this connection is now canon in the
MCU.
The idea of the combined film and TV universe comes packaged with many
frustrating plot questions. Fans are baffled as to why Tony Stark would
recruit Spider-Man when Daredevil, Luke Cage, and Jessica Jones are much
more capable. How can the federal government launch a department to
hunt the Inhumans with The Avengers not even hearing about them? How can
The Hand nearly destroy all of New York without intelligence expert
Natasha Romanov noticing something is wrong? All of this is hard to
reconcile. Logistically, Marvel executives have given us many reasons
for these failure in connectivity, citing vastly different production
schedules and different story goals. However, narratively, fans yearn
for canon explanations that can make this supposedly connected universe
feel less like a marketing ploy and more like a living and breathing
world.
But for now, all fans can do is wait. And in the meantime, the solitary
example of Metro General will just have to be enough to tide us over.
https://www.geezgo.com/sps/32620
Comments
Post a Comment